Years ago in the pre-Brett Favre doldrums of the 80s, Paul Hornung did the color commentary for the Packers' pre-season games. I heard the play-by-play announcer (I don't remember his name) tell how ill prepared he was. Before the first pre-season game, Hornung would step into the booth, plop a media guide with all the players' names in it and declare, "Alright, let's go!"
This story along with his incorrect perception of Notre Dame football illustrates how ignorant the "Golden Boy" can be.
Here's one more item from Hornung's own mouth. While apologizing on the Dan Patrick show today, Hornung told a story of former ND coach Lou Holtz showing him a list of the top 50 high school prospects at the time. The ND administration told him he could only go after three of them because the rest didn't have the academic qualifications to get into ND. It sounds like this proves Hornung's point. One problem, Holtz won. Here's just a portion of his accomplishments at ND:
Holtz quickly proved that he could take Notre Dame back to the top of the college football world and keep the program there on a consistent basis. In just his third season at Notre Dame, Holtz led the Fighting Irish to the 1988 national championship with a perfect 12-0 record, a season in which he earned National Coach of the Year honors. Facing what was rated by the NCAA as the nation’s most difficult schedule three times during his tenure with the Irish and the toughest over a five-year period from 1986-90, Holtz’s record was a sparkling 100-30-2 at Notre Dame, including an 87-20-2 mark over his last nine seasons at the school. Holtz coached the Irish to finishes of sixth or better in the final Associated Press poll in five seasons and his five postseason bowl victories at Notre Dame are more than any other Irish coach. Additionally during his tenure at Notre Dame, Holtz compiled a 33-20-2 mark against AP top 25 teams and a 21-15-1 record vs. AP top 10 squads. Holtz led Notre Dame into 22 different games with the number one ranking in the current AP poll and three times his Irish teams knocked off the nation’s number one ranked team. His teams reeled off 23 consecutive victories through the 1988 and ‘89 seasons to establish the longest winning streak in Notre Dame history. Holtz tutored a long list of All-Americas at Notre Dame, including Heisman Trophy winner Tim Brown and Lombardi Award winners Chris Zorich and Aaron Taylor. While he was at Notre Dame, Holtz had 12 players selected in the first round of the NFL draft, including seven combined in the 1993 and ‘94 drafts.Holtz has been the only coach to win a national championship in the same year both on the field in 1988 as well as in the classroom, as evidenced by the 100 percent graduation rate of Notre Dame football players in winning the 1988 CFA Academic Award. Three times during his stay at South Bend, his Fighting Irish squads achieved the highest graduation rates in the country.
Not bad for a guy who couldn't go after the best talent. That's something Hornung should think about.
"Hornung: Irish Should Still Lower Standards"
Comments (4)
So, tell me, if Mr. Golden ... (Below threshold)1. Posted by Tom | April 1, 2004 3:05 AM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
So, tell me, if Mr. Golden Boy is so wrong, why is it, exactly, that the vast majority of universities in America DO lower their standards in order to let more Blacks in? Gee, could it be because, in general, Black academic success is . . . lacking?
If you answer "no" to that, then you must believe that any and all educational Affimative Action programs should be ended immediately and without delay, because they're no longer needed. If Blacks, generally, do as well academically Whites, then they do not need any further help in achieving equality in this regard, whether it be at ND or anywhere else.
All Hornung did was point out one of the sad realities of life. His observation was correct, even if his conclusion (that ND should place athletic excellence at a higher value than academic excellence and act accordingly) is seriously flawed.
It always amazes me that people never sicken of their own self-righteous, politically correct bs. If you don't care for his opinions, great. But you (and many others) seem to think that while you should have a right to shove your indignation down Hornung's throat, he should not have the right to speak his mind, even if what he says is accurate.
What makes you think that your own opinion is in some way more valuable or worthwhile than his? Oh, right, because you have the Thought Police on your side, therefore Hornung is an immoral scumbag and you a paragon of virtue.
1. Posted by Tom | April 1, 2004 3:05 AM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on April 1, 2004 03:05
2. Posted by Sean Hackbarth | April 1, 2004 8:58 PM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
I'm no fan of affirmative action. I just pointed out some facts that run contrary to Hornung's argument. He's not a bright guy when it comes to things off the football field.
2. Posted by Sean Hackbarth | April 1, 2004 8:58 PM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on April 1, 2004 20:58
3. Posted by Margarita | April 8, 2004 3:24 PM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION IS NOT ABOUT LOWERING STANDARDS PEOPLE! AFFIRMATIVE ACTION IS INTENDED TO ENSURE EQUALITY OF STANDARDS!
LET'S NOT GET THAT CONFUSED!
3. Posted by Margarita | April 8, 2004 3:24 PM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on April 8, 2004 15:24
4. Posted by Sean Hackbarth | April 8, 2004 9:27 PM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
That's certainly not how most affirmative action programs operate. The goal is to get a specific group to statistically represent the surrounding population. Quotas, lowering of standards, and "goals and timetables" are used to try to achieve that. For an international survey, I recommend Thomas Sowell's _Affirmative Action Around the World_ for plenty of examples of standards lowered to achieve a particular racial outcome.
4. Posted by Sean Hackbarth | April 8, 2004 9:27 PM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on April 8, 2004 21:27